Discover
Find exactly the cookie you want. Sort by any characteristic to see which recipes rank highest and why.
Show me the...
Dietary preferences
Which cookies are the chewiest?
Chewy cookies have more brown sugar, higher hydration, melted butter, and less flour relative to fat.
J. Kenji López-Alt · Serious Eats · 2013
5/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 720min chill
Alton Brown · Good Eats / Food Network · 2000
5/5
Why it's chewy: 4.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 60min chill
Levain Bakery (adapted) · Levain Bakery / Various Copycat Recipes · 1995
5/5
Why it's chewy: 1.70x more brown than white sugar | 60min chill
America's Test Kitchen · America's Test Kitchen / Cook's Illustrated · 2009
5/5
Why it's chewy: 1.98x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
David Leite / Jacques Torres · The New York Times · 2009
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.25x more brown than white sugar | 2160min chill
David Leite · The New York Times · 2008
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.25x more brown than white sugar | 2160min chill
Cook's Illustrated · Cook's Illustrated · 2014
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.49x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Allrecipes Member · allrecipes.com · 1999
4/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
King Arthur Test Kitchen · kingarthurbaking.com
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.13x more brown than white sugar
Chris Morocco · bonappetit.com · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: 4.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | high hydration (0.43)
Molly Marzalek-Kelly · kingarthurbaking.com · 2023
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.65) | 4320min chill
Chef Joshua Weissman · joshuaweissman.com · 2026
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 720min chill
Abby Girl · food.com · 2006
4/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Val Goodrich · tasteofhome.com · 2018
4/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.65x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.42)
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.65x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.37)
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.15x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.42) | 720min chill
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.37)
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2022
4/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.40)
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2024
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
Alvin Zhou · tasty.co · 2017
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (1.04)
Joy the Baker · joythebaker.com · 2014
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com
4/5
Why it's chewy: 6.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | high hydration (0.92) | 720min chill
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2013
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.38) | 120min chill
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.53) | 120min chill
Nagi · recipetineats.com · 2025
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
The Recipe Critic · therecipecritic.com · 2022
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
Erin Clarke / Well Plated · wellplated.com · 2023
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.87x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.38)
Erin Clarke · wellplated.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.39)
Morgan · hostthetoast.com · 2015
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Nagi · recipetineats.com · 2023
4/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.39)
Chef Joshua Weissman · joshuaweissman.com · 2025
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.48x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Kate Davis · bonappetit.com · 2017
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.94x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | high hydration (0.40)
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.87)
Lauren Habermehl · tasteofhome.com · 2025
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.46)
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2024
4/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.48) | 1440min chill
Martha Stewart · marthastewart.com · 2011
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Amanda Rettke · iambaker.net · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Allison Mattina · celebratingsweets.com · 2022
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
null · food52.com
4/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.35)
Andrew Bernard · makeitdairyfree.com · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (1.43)
Bianca Zapatka · biancazapatka.com · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.78)
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.38)
null · food52.com · 2015
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
MissLinguist · food.com · 2007
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
The Giggle Box · food.com · 2003
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2025
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.48)
Monique Volz of Ambitious Kitchen · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Monique of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com
4/5
Why it's chewy: 4.20x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | high hydration (0.46)
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2021
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Stephanie · iamafoodblog.com · 2022
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.54x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.70)
Ashley Manila · bakerbynature.com · 2015
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.79)
TalPalCal · food.com · 2008
4/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.37)
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.46)
Sarah Jampel · kingarthurbaking.com
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.62x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.38)
Ashley Manila · bakerbynature.com · 2025
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.12x more brown than white sugar
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
Tonkcats · food.com · 1999
4/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: 5.50x more brown than white sugar
NIN4NIN · food.com · 2007
4/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.42)
AmyZoe · food.com · 2012
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.54)
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2022
4/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Wendy Griffin · food.com · 2000
4/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2015
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
Lena Abraham · delish.com · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
Mizzy · food.com · 2004
4/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
smltheppl · food.com · 2005
4/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Tinkerbell · food.com · 2008
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.35)
Edited by Angela Ritchie · bettycrocker.com · 2005
4/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Codii Lopez · tasty.co · 2019
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.46)
Unknown · epicurious.com · 2018
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
KisaJ · food.com · 2009
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.59x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.71)
Sharon Lehman, RDN · tasteofhome.com · 2018
4/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
Modern Honey® - www.modernhoney.com · modernhoney.com · 2024
4/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (1.31) | 1440min chill
Ashley Manila · bakerbynature.com · 2020
4/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | 120min chill
Ruth Wakefield · Nestlé / Toll House Inn · 1938
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.10x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Christina Tosi · Milk Bar / Momofuku Milk Bar Cookbook · 2011
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.59x more brown than white sugar | 60min chill
DoubleTree by Hilton · DoubleTree by Hilton · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.10x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Irma S. Rombauer / Marion Rombauer Becker / Ethan Becker · Joy of Cooking · 1975
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.10x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
ELIZABETHBH · allrecipes.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
Val Goodrich · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
King Arthur Baking · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.13x more brown than white sugar
King Arthur Test Kitchen · kingarthurbaking.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.52) | 180min chill
Emma Christensen · simplyrecipes.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.07x more brown than white sugar
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Jess Rice · budgetbytes.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.69x more brown than white sugar
Melissa Stadler, Modern Honey · modernhoney.com · 2015
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
Unknown · epicurious.com · 2004
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.40)
Makinze Gore · delish.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 240min chill
Gaby Dalkin · whatsgabycooking.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.08x more brown than white sugar
David Turner · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.52) | 180min chill
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
Makinze Gore · delish.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 240min chill
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2015
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.65x more brown than white sugar | 60min chill
Karen=^..^= · food.com · 2002
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
Betty · food.com · 2001
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Lisa A. Kaminski · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
Lisa A. Kaminski · tasteofhome.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.52) | 180min chill
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.47x more brown than white sugar
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.50x more brown than white sugar | 1440min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.50x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 120min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.50x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.45) | 120min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.67x more brown than white sugar
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 1440min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (1.03)
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.22x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.37)
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.65x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36) | 720min chill
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Cookie and Kate · cookieandkate.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.53)
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2014
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
Scott Loitsch · tasty.co · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Lauren Wilson · tasty.co · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.17x more brown than white sugar
Makinze Gore · delish.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Melissa Stadler · modernhoney.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar | 1440min chill
Nora · noracooks.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Ashley Manila · bakerbynature.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nisha Vora · rainbowplantlife.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.94x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 1440min chill
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Natasha Kravchuk · natashaskitchen.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Ree Drummond · thepioneerwoman.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | 120min chill
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2015
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | 180min chill
Natasha Kravchuk · natashaskitchen.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Mary Younkin · barefeetinthekitchen.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
The Recipe Critic · therecipecritic.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
The Recipe Critic · therecipecritic.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 4.00x more brown than white sugar
Amanda Rettke · iambaker.net · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.87)
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.75x more brown than white sugar
Karina Carrel · cafedelites.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Samantha · spendwithpennies.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.50x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Spend With Pennies · spendwithpennies.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Gina Homolka · skinnytaste.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (1.04)
Gina Homolka · skinnytaste.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.90)
Sabrina Snyder · dinnerthendessert.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar
Sabrina Snyder · dinnerthendessert.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.71) | 60min chill
Sonja Overhiser · acouplecooks.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.87x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 60min chill
Sonja Overhiser · acouplecooks.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Sonja Overhiser · acouplecooks.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Sonja Overhiser · acouplecooks.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.64)
Joanne Gallagher · inspiredtaste.net · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Kelly Senyei · justataste.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.67x more brown than white sugar
Kelly Senyei · justataste.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Kelly Senyei · justataste.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.56) | 120min chill
Mel · melskitchencafe.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Mel · melskitchencafe.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
David · davidlebovitz.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.45)
Suzy Karadsheh · themediterraneandish.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.34x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Yumna Jawad · feelgoodfoodie.net · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.49)
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Michele · paleorunningmomma.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.35)
Charlotte Rutledge · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Arman Liew · thebigmansworld.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (2.68)
Sweet Basil · ohsweetbasil.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Trish - Mom On Timeout · momontimeout.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.80x more brown than white sugar
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40) | 120min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.67x more brown than white sugar
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.53)
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 120min chill
Sweet Basil · ohsweetbasil.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.75x more brown than white sugar
Modern Honey - www.modernhoney.com · modernhoney.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
null · food52.com · 2014
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.38)
null · food52.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.37)
null · food52.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.44)
null · food52.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.39)
Unknown · epicurious.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.53)
Emma Christensen · thekitchn.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Nicole Rufus · thekitchn.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40) | 720min chill
Jodie Kautzmann · foodandwine.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 240min chill
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Alvin Zhou · tasty.co · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 2160min chill
Modern Honey® - www.modernhoney.com · modernhoney.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 2880min chill
Emilie Raffa · theclevercarrot.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.19x more brown than white sugar
Kayla Burton · brokenovenbaking.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
David · davidlebovitz.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.39x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.39)
Martin Philip · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.13x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.37)
Aaron Hutcherson · thekitchn.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
null · food52.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.07x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.42)
Betty Crocker Kitchens · bettycrocker.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.41)
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.47) | 120min chill
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2015
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | 120min chill
Claire Nolan · tasty.co · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 120min chill
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 4.00x more brown than white sugar
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.38)
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 4.00x more brown than white sugar
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2012
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: 120min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | 1440min chill
Trish - Mom On Timeout · momontimeout.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Lindsay D. Mattison · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (1.52)
Lauren Allen · tastesbetterfromscratch.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.52) | 180min chill
Allison Mattina · celebratingsweets.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Ree Drummond · thepioneerwoman.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Sabrina Snyder · dinnerthendessert.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 7.00x more brown than white sugar
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
null · food52.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
null · food52.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Pick Up Limes · pickuplimes.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.30x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Pick Up Limes · pickuplimes.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Angela Liddon · ohsheglows.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Jeanine Donofrio · loveandlemons.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Mary Younkin · barefeetinthekitchen.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Andrew Bernard · makeitdairyfree.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Arman Liew · thebigmansworld.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Nora · noracooks.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Ela · elavegan.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Julie | The Simple Veganista · simple-veganista.com · 2014
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.51)
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Pick Up Limes · pickuplimes.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.45)
Andrew Bernard · makeitdairyfree.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nora · noracooks.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Andrew Bernard · makeitdairyfree.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 5.33x more brown than white sugar
Arman Liew · thebigmansworld.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Justine · justinesnacks.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nora · noracooks.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Nora · noracooks.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.47)
Nisha Vora · rainbowplantlife.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2012
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.42)
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.41)
Brittany Mullins · eatingbirdfood.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2014
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Andrew Bernard · makeitdairyfree.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
null · food52.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Unknown · womensweeklyfood.com.au · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Adrianna Adarme · acozykitchen.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Rosemary Molloy · anitalianinmykitchen.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.47)
David · davidlebovitz.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.71)
Wish I Could Cook · food.com · 2011
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
hipbonez · food.com · 2007
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Chrishanna · food.com · 2011
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
Feej3940 · food.com · 2007
3/5
Why it's chewy: 5.00x more brown than white sugar | 60min chill
skinnysweetsdaily · food.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.58)
null · food52.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
zaiida · cookpad.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.40)
Macintosh · cookpad.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.67x more brown than white sugar
LazyHata · cookpad.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.36) | 60min chill
Cora Williams · cookpad.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
tunasushi · food.com · 2006
3/5
Why it's chewy: 5.60x more brown than white sugar
blucoat · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Kathy-Lynn · food.com · 2001
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.13x more brown than white sugar
Oolala · food.com · 2005
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.40)
Genius Kitchen · food.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.48)
pollen · food.com · 2002
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar
Jeanine Donofrio · loveandlemons.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Jeanine Donofrio · loveandlemons.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Ree Drummond · thepioneerwoman.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Erin Merhar · thepioneerwoman.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar
Makinze Gore · delish.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 240min chill
Namiko Hirasawa Chen · justonecookbook.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Monique Volz of Ambitious Kitchen · ambitiouskitchen.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.39)
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.75x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | 120min chill
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Unknown · iamafoodblog.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Adrianna Adarme · acozykitchen.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
HeatherFeather · food.com · 2003
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Southwest Chef from · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
ladyroseofrohan · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
PENNY · food.com · 2004
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Kim - InsanelyGood · insanelygoodrecipes.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Makinze Gore · delish.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 240min chill
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Melissa Stadler, Modern Honey · modernhoney.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 120min chill
Michele · paleorunningmomma.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.35)
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.36)
Adrianna Adarme · acozykitchen.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Team · kitchenstories.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Melissa Stadler, Modern Honey · modernhoney.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 7.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Stella Parks · seriouseats.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.10x more brown than white sugar
Adrianna Adarme · acozykitchen.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.87x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Linky · food.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Brandon Gouveia · tasty.co · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Yumna Jawad · feelgoodfoodie.net · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
i_luv_chocolate · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
Kim - InsanelyGood · insanelygoodrecipes.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 5.18x more brown than white sugar
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Ashley Manila · bakerbynature.com · 2026
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.43)
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.06x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.42)
KCShell · food.com · 2005
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.35)
senseicheryl · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.51)
nobmx · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Michele · paleorunningmomma.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2014
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar | 120min chill
Aimee · lmld.org · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Karina Carrel · cafedelites.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.80) | 720min chill
Kittencalrecipezazz · food.com · 2007
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36)
Lauren Allen · tastesbetterfromscratch.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar
Mirj2338 · food.com · 2001
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
King Arthur Test Kitchen · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.35)
Steven John · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Robyn Stone · addapinch.com · 2013
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar
Charlotte Rutledge · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.49x more brown than white sugar
Hersheyland · hersheyland.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Carrie Forrest, MPH in Nutrition · cleaneatingkitchen.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Kelly Senyei · justataste.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.36) | 60min chill
Elizabeth LaBau · sugarhero.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 4.26x more brown than white sugar | 4320min chill
Nagi | RecipeTin · recipetineats.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Candace Braun Davison · delish.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: 5.00x more brown than white sugar
mileen · food.com · 2012
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (4.15)
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Smadars Sane Way Cc · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.42)
Laura Rege · delish.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.49)
Monique Volz of Ambitious Kitchen · ambitiouskitchen.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (3.57)
Katie Bandurski · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 5.00x more brown than white sugar
Rachel Gaewski · tasty.co · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar
Pierce Abernathy · tasty.co · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Monique of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (5.76)
trippism · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Nan Bialek · tasteofhome.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (4.17)
Charishma_Ramchandani · food.com · 2001
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Raw Spice Bar · food.com · 2015
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.44)
Baby Kato · food.com · 2012
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.71)
Chocolatl · food.com · 2012
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Sherri L. · food.com · 2014
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.38)
Hetal Vasavada · tasteofhome.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.10x more brown than white sugar
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.52)
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Brittney Nourie · bettycrocker.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 60min chill
Kat's Mom · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.33x more brown than white sugar
Ali · gimmesomeoven.com · 2025
3/5
Why it's chewy: 3.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | 120min chill
Makinze Gore · delish.com · 2021
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | high hydration (0.37)
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 6.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Namiko Hirasawa Chen · justonecookbook.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.37)
Kathy · food.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Marg (CaymanDesigns) · food.com · 2004
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Steve_G · food.com · 2004
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
David · davidlebovitz.com · 2016
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.58)
Alan in SW Florida · food.com · 2006
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.60)
HokiesMom · food.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Kelsey Dimberg · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | 60min chill
justcallmetoni · food.com · 2007
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (1.23)
Meghan · food.com · 2010
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Evil Eva · food.com · 2007
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
mersaydees · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
Sydney Mike · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.68)
Susan Reid · kingarthurbaking.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.12x more brown than white sugar
Morning Biscotti · food.com · 2006
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Lesley Balla · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
Sparkle 1874 · food.com · 2006
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.40)
The12yroldchef · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
HeatherFeather · food.com · 2007
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
shygirl · food.com · 2008
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
sofie-a-toast · food.com · 2011
3/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Country Cookin Mama · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.88)
blucoat · food.com · 2009
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.68)
Felix4067 · food.com · 2002
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.52)
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2019
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.80)
Val Goodrich · tasteofhome.com · 2018
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Sophia Saxonhouse · tasty.co · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Claire Nolan · tasty.co · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.50x more brown than white sugar
Keturah Green · tasty.co · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.05x more brown than white sugar
Unknown · epicurious.com · 2023
3/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Unknown · epicurious.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.06x more brown than white sugar
Shilpa Uskokovic · bonappetit.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
null · food52.com
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.00x more brown than white sugar
Kelley Simmons · chefsavvy.com · 2017
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.10x more brown than white sugar | 720min chill
Kelley Simmons · chefsavvy.com · 2020
3/5
Why it's chewy: 1.40x more brown than white sugar
Cambrea Gordon · cambreabakes.com · 2024
3/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | high hydration (0.38)
Justine · justinesnacks.com · 2022
3/5
Why it's chewy: 2.36x more brown than white sugar | browned butter | high hydration (0.56)
Sarah Kieffer · The Vanilla Bean Baking Book / The New York Times · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Dora · allrecipes.com · 1998
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.08x more brown than white sugar
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2012
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2022
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | 120min chill
Lindsay Ostrom · pinchofyum.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Nagi · recipetineats.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Amanda Rettke · iambaker.net · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.13x more brown than white sugar | 2160min chill
Laura · joyfoodsunshine.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sophie Godwin – Cookery writer · bbcgoodfood.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Spend With Pennies · spendwithpennies.com · 2022
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Erin Clarke · wellplated.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
Sabrina Snyder · dinnerthendessert.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | 60min chill
Jamie Oliver · jamieoliver.com · 2016
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.43)
PJ Hamel · kingarthurbaking.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2013
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
Jeanine Donofrio · loveandlemons.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | 120min chill
Edited by Angela Ritchie · bettycrocker.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Mimi in Maine · food.com · 2007
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Meryl · food.com · 2002
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Miryam MS · food.com · 2008
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
kelly123 · food.com · 2002
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
AnnNH · food.com · 2005
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
tunasushi · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Jonathan Brasil · kingarthurbaking.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.08x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
King Arthur Baking · kingarthurbaking.com · 2022
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.42x more brown than white sugar | 60min chill
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.39)
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Cookie and Kate · cookieandkate.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Cookie and Kate · cookieandkate.com · 2011
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alvin Zhou · tasty.co · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Lindsay Ostrom · pinchofyum.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | browned butter
Laura · joyfoodsunshine.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nicole Hunn · glutenfreeonashoestring.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: 720min chill
Lisa Bass · farmhouseonboone.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.04x more brown than white sugar
Jamie · mybakingaddiction.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Jamie · mybakingaddiction.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 2160min chill
Nagi · recipetineats.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
The Recipe Critic · therecipecritic.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Sam Merritt · sugarspunrun.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Erin Clarke · wellplated.com · 2022
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Gina Homolka · skinnytaste.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.36)
Sabrina Snyder · dinnerthendessert.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Mel Gunnell · melskitchencafe.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Mel · melskitchencafe.com · 2015
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Mel · melskitchencafe.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Allison Mattina · celebratingsweets.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
Lauren Allen · tastesbetterfromscratch.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Val Goodrich · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
love4culinary · food.com · 2003
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Christine Fiorentino · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Maria Lichty · twopeasandtheirpod.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
null · food52.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Ree Drummond · thepioneerwoman.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Ree Drummond · thepioneerwoman.com · 2010
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.54)
Maeve R · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Codii Lopez · tasty.co · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
null · food52.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | 720min chill
Valerie Barrett · bbcgoodfood.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
mummamills · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.57)
Amanda Rettke--iambaker.net · iambaker.net · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.25x more brown than white sugar
Averie Sunshine · averiecooks.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter
Trish - Mom On Timeout · momontimeout.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | 120min chill
Nagi · recipetineats.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
John Kanell · preppykitchen.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
null · food52.com · 2015
2/5
Why it's chewy: 720min chill
null · food52.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
King Arthur Baking · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.06x more brown than white sugar
King Arthur Baking · kingarthurbaking.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.06x more brown than white sugar | 720min chill
Betty Crocker Kitchens · bettycrocker.com · 2014
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Bianca Zapatka · biancazapatka.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Ania · lazycatkitchen.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Ania · lazycatkitchen.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: 720min chill
Julie | The Simple Veganista · simple-veganista.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nora · noracooks.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Sam Turnbull @ It Doesn't Taste Like Chicken · itdoesnttastelikechicken.com · 2016
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Nora · noracooks.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Nisha Vora · rainbowplantlife.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2015
2/5
Why it's chewy: 120min chill
null · food52.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.43)
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.71)
Andrew Bernard · makeitdairyfree.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Brittany Mullins · eatingbirdfood.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nora · noracooks.com · 2022
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | 60min chill
Bianca Zapatka · biancazapatka.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Angela Liddon · ohsheglows.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Arman Liew · thebigmansworld.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.39)
Unknown · forksoverknives.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alyssa · simplyquinoa.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alison Andrews · lovingitvegan.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Jamie Oliver · jamieoliver.com · 2016
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Timothy Pakron · jamieoliver.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Shelly · cookiesandcups.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Unknown · onceuponachef.com · 2014
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.46)
Roosie · food.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
PrudenceWichett · food.com · 2007
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
OrangeLuna · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
BB2011 · food.com · 2010
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Nicole_85 · food.com · 2005
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
sofie-a-toast · food.com · 2010
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Savanna · food.com · 2007
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
creativelyvegan · food.com · 2013
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
ChefArani · food.com · 2011
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Elanas Pantry · food.com · 2008
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Whats Cooking · food.com · 2007
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
KDub275 · food.com · 2008
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
null · food52.com · 2013
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Asseel Ussama · cookpad.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.43x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.52)
Johnsdeere · food.com · 2009
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
chefamarie · food.com · 2009
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
King Arthur Test Kitchen · kingarthurbaking.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.09x more brown than white sugar
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
June Xie · delish.com · 2016
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Lauren Miyashiro · delish.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Monique Volz of AmbitiousKitchen.com · ambitiouskitchen.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.45)
Lisa Bryan · downshiftology.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Adrianna Adarme · acozykitchen.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.36)
Modern Honey® - www.modernhoney.com · modernhoney.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Mary Berry · thehappyfoodie.co.uk · 2016
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
LIDIA'S RESTAURANT · lidiasitaly.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Cathleen Colbert · food.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | high hydration (0.50)
Sabrina Snyder · dinnerthendessert.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Arman Liew · thebigmansworld.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Becky Hardin · thecookierookie.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Laura · joyfoodsunshine.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Adrianna Adarme · acozykitchen.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Stacey Little · southernbite.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2012
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Laura · joyfoodsunshine.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Sally · sallysbakingaddiction.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: 240min chill
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Addison LaBonte · organicallyaddison.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
McCormick Kitchens · mccormick.com · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Kristi Waterworth · food.com · 2008
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Erin Clarke · wellplated.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Erin Clarke · wellplated.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (1.79)
Betty Crocker Kitchens · bettycrocker.com · 2012
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Abba Gimel · food.com · 2010
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Lena Abraham · delish.com · 2017
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
rainna · food.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Chef Ryoni · food.com · 2009
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
amyelice · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
spatchcock · food.com · 2003
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
flppyft · food.com · 2007
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Kree · food.com · 2003
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
luvthezaar · food.com · 2007
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Tasty · tasty.co · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.35) | 60min chill
Tieghan Gerard · halfbakedharvest.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Leahs Kitchen · food.com · 2010
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Ruchika Soni · tasty.co · 2021
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Tessa Arias · handletheheat.com · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: browned butter | 2880min chill
Kat Lieu · tasty.co · 2025
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
David · davidlebovitz.com · 2010
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.10x more brown than white sugar
Natasha Feldman · food.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Kim D. · food.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Marie · food.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Tisme · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
evelynathens · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: 90min chill
Dawn Konofaos · kingarthurbaking.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Joelle Park · tasty.co · 2024
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Cooking to Perfecti · food.com · 2002
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
ReeLani · food.com · 2004
2/5
Why it's chewy: 60min chill
I_Cook_For_Firemen · food.com · 2008
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
F-16 momma · food.com · 2006
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Alexa Hackfort · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: 120min chill
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Taste of Home Editorial Team · tasteofhome.com · 2018
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | 120min chill
Betty Crocker Kitchens · bettycrocker.com · 2019
2/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter | high hydration (0.64)
Betty Crocker Kitchens · bettycrocker.com · 2012
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.96)
Marianne Williams · tasty.co · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar | melted butter | high hydration (0.49)
Unknown · epicurious.com · 2023
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Carol Bullock · food.com · 2001
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
ellie_ · food.com · 2005
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Elizabeth Fullerton · food.com · 2001
2/5
Why it's chewy: 1.00x more brown than white sugar
Chahinez Tabet Aoul · lifestyleofafoodie.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
Izzy · izzycooking.com · 2020
2/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.61)
Minimalist Baker · minimalistbaker.com · 2012
2/5
Why it's chewy: balanced recipe
null · food52.com
2/5
Why it's chewy: 720min chill
Alton Brown · Good Eats / Food Network · 2000
1/5
Why it's chewy: high hydration (0.44)
Alton Brown · Good Eats / Food Network · 2000
1/5
Why it's chewy: melted butter
Kathleen King · Tate's Bake Shop · 1980
1/5
Why it's chewy: 1.65x more brown than white sugar | melted butter