← Hot Dog Atlas · United States and Canada
New York street cart hot dog
New York City · also called dirty water dog
An all-beef frank, often kept in a street cart's hot water bath, on a plain bun with spicy brown mustard and either sauerkraut, onions cooked down in a tomato-based sauce, or both.
Recipes
5
of 529 in the atlas
Sites
5
most from 24kitchen.nl
Languages
3
Dutch, English, French
Usual build
3 of 6
parts in the median recipe · 1 have all
New York street cart hot dog, by the usual definition
- All-beef frank
- Boiled or simmered
- Plain soft bun
- Spicy brown or grainy mustard
- Sauerkraut
- Onions in red sauce (New York)
1 of 5 published recipes have every part; the median recipe has 3 of 6. Where the rest depart: frank, unstated instead of all-beef (4), no brown mustard (4), no onion sauce (3), no boiled (2).
| Recipe | All-beef | Boiled | Plain bun | Brown mustard | Sauerkraut | Onion sauce |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| amazingribs.comNew York Style Hot Dog With Onion Sauce Recipe | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| cherrypick.coNYC Style Hot Dogs With Street Cart Onions | ◐ | ● | ● | ○ | ● | ● |
| 24kitchen.nlNew York style hotdogs | ◐ | ● | ● | ○ | ● | ○ |
| chefsimon.comHot-Dog comme à NYC | ◐ | ○ | ● | ○ | ● | ○ |
| laurasbakery.nlBbq hot dog New York stijl | ◐ | ○ | ● | ○ | ○ | ○ |
| Recipes with it | 1 | 3 | 5 | 1 | 4 | 2 |
● has it · ◐ something else stands in · ○ left out
Everything its recipes use
The share of New York recipes naming each component, by kind, with the share of all hot dogs as a tick.
Sausage
- Frank or wiener, type not stated80% · 4 · all 77%
- All-beef frankusual20% · 1 · all 10%
Bun or wrap
- Plain soft bunusual100% · 5 · all 56%
Cooking
- Boiled or simmeredusual60% · 3 · all 20%
- Grilled20% · 1 · all 18%
- Griddled or pan-fried20% · 1 · all 13%
Toppings
- Raw onion80% · 4 · all 37%
- Sauerkrautusual80% · 4 · all 4%
- Crispy fried onions20% · 1 · all 6%
- Fresh tomato20% · 1 · all 20%
Sauces and condiments
- Ketchup60% · 3 · all 35%
- Tomato sauce or paste60% · 3 · all 12%
- Mustard, kind not stated40% · 2 · all 33%
- Onions in red sauce (New York)usual40% · 2 · all <1%
- Yellow mustard20% · 1 · all 10%
- Spicy brown or grainy mustardusual20% · 1 · all 3%
- Dijon mustard20% · 1 · all 3%
What sets it apart
- Onions in red sauce (New York) in 2 of 5 recipes (40%), against <1% of all hot dogs: more than ten times as common.
- Sauerkraut in 4 of 5 recipes (80%), against 4% of all hot dogs: more than ten times as common.
- Tomato sauce or paste in 3 of 5 recipes (60%), against 12% of all hot dogs: 5 times as common.
- Boiled or simmered in 3 of 5 recipes (60%), against 20% of all hot dogs: 3 times as common.
- Raw onion in 4 of 5 recipes (80%), against 37% of all hot dogs: 2 times as common.
The 5 New York recipes
Each names the style in its title. Beside each, how much of the usual build it has.
- Bbq hot dog New York stijl · laurasbakery.nl · Dutch1 of 6 usual parts · no all-beef frank, boiled or simmered, spicy brown or grainy mustard
- Hot-Dog comme à NYC · chefsimon.com · French2 of 6 usual parts · no all-beef frank, boiled or simmered, spicy brown or grainy mustard
- New York Style Hot Dog With Onion Sauce Recipe · amazingribs.com6 of 6 usual parts
- New York style hotdogs · 24kitchen.nl · Dutch3 of 6 usual parts · no all-beef frank, spicy brown or grainy mustard, onions in red sauce (New York)
- NYC Style Hot Dogs With Street Cart Onions · cherrypick.co4 of 6 usual parts · no all-beef frank, spicy brown or grainy mustard
Styles most like it
By what their recipes use more often than hot dogs in general.