Pizza Lab5,130 recipes
← All pizzas

New York Sicilian Pizza

James Delmage · sipandfeast.com · 2022 · Original

Sicilianas labeled by the source

DietVegetarian. Not vegan: pecorino romano, low moisture whole milk mozzarella.

Against 5,130 pizza recipes

Sicilian style, 64% hydration: drier than 58% of the 1,480 doughs that parse, baked at 430°F, hotter than 55% of recipes that state an oven.

See how all 5,130 pizza recipes compare →

Sicilian (Sicily): thick spongy crumb, often with anchovy/breadcrumb/caciocavallo; sometimes cheeseless

Tradition: 65 to 75% hydration (this recipe: 64%) · 450 to 550°F bake (this recipe: 430°F)

Baker's percentages

Every ingredient as a percentage of the flour weight (flour = 100%), the way bakers compare doughs across batch sizes.

Flour

497g

Water

318g

Hydration

64.0%

Salt

2.6%

Yeast

0.40%

Oil

14.4%

Sauce

28g

Cheese

19g

Dough weight

1248g

Process

Bake temp

430°F / 221°C

Bake time

12 min

Oven

home standard

Surface

stone

Bulk

3h

Ingredients (10)

  • flourbread flour497g
  • yeastinstant dry yeast2g
  • saltfine sea salt10g
  • sugargranulated sugar6g
  • watercold water318g
  • oilolive oil1/4 cup · 54.5g
  • sauce tomato1 28-ounce can crushed plum tomatoes1 oz · 28.3g
  • saltkosher salt1/2 tsp · 3g
  • cheese otherPecorino Romano3 tbsp · 18.9g
  • dairy doughlow moisture whole milk mozzarella12 oz · 340g

Toppings (1)

Position matters: under the cheese steams, over the cheese roasts, post-bake stays fresh.

  • over cheeseSicilian dried oregano1 tsp · 0.5g

Keep exploring

Or browse all 5130 pizza recipes.